Articles

Judge Clears Peraire-Bueno Brothers, Ending First US Criminal MEV Case

Coinvote

由 Coinvote

Judge Clears Peraire-Bueno Brothers, Ending First US Criminal MEV Case

A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of fraud and laundering charges tied to a $25 million strike on Ethereum trading bots. The ruling ends the first US criminal prosecution over MEV and shows how fraud law treats open blockchain networks.

Judge enters acquittal and closes the case without a retrial

A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, ending the US government's case over an April 2023 trade that cost automated Ethereum trading bots about $25 million. Decrypt reports that Judge Jessica Clarke approved the brothers' acquittal request on Monday. That means there will be no second trial.

The legal hinge was a single element of wire fraud. Prosecutors had to prove a material misrepresentation, and Cointelegraph reported that Clarke concluded no false promise was made in the trades, so that element was not met. CoinDesk summarized the ruling as finding that the trade involved no lie that anyone relied on.

The judge kept her holding narrow. Protos noted that the opinion addresses only whether the trial evidence could support a conviction. In the words Decrypt quotes, the question was not whether the conduct was right or moral, or whether it broke laws the brothers were never charged under.

How the April 2023 trade worked

The case centered on MEV-Boost, software through which Ethereum validators can outsource transaction sequencing to specialist block builders. Decrypt explained that the targets were sandwich bots, automated traders that capture maximal extractable value by trading immediately before and after other users' transactions.

According to the ruling as described by Decrypt, the brothers posted bait transactions meant to attract particular bots. They then exploited a flaw in the relay software to view the bots' bundled trades ahead of their inclusion in a block. The bait was replaced with trades that sold the tokens, and the bots lost roughly $25 million within about 12 seconds.

Protos adds that the brothers ran an Ethereum validator and that the flaw sat in the MEV-boost relay run by Flashbots. It also reported that the pair soon afterward revealed a separate exploit under the Low Carb Crusader pseudonym.

The numbers and dates that frame the case

The outlets match on the main figures but differ somewhat in how they lay out the timeline.

  • About $25 million taken from trading bots in roughly 12 seconds, in April 2023 (Decrypt, Protos, Cointelegraph).
  • Authorities arrested the pair in May 2024, per Decrypt, while Protos says they were indicted that month.
  • A jury deadlocked and a mistrial followed in November 2025, according to Decrypt and Cointelegraph.
  • Acquittal on Monday, with Protos describing the earlier trial as lasting weeks.

Where the outlets agree and where they differ

All four outlets report the acquittal, the $25 million figure and the missing misrepresentation. Cointelegraph and Protos both note that Clarke cited the Mango Markets case involving Avraham Eisenberg. Cointelegraph dates that precedent to 2025 and Protos to last year, and both describe similar reasoning about the absence of false statements.

The accounts diverge on the charge list. Protos reports four charges: wire fraud, along with conspiracy counts tied to wire fraud, money laundering and receiving stolen property. Decrypt names the first three as the counts the brothers were cleared of and explains that the laundering count fell because it depended on the fraud proceeds. Readers should treat the stolen-property count as reported by Protos alone.

Each outlet also adds something the others lack. Decrypt reports a footnote in which Clarke noted that the prosecution brings up serious due process issues, a question she chose not to decide. Decrypt also describes testimony from an insider about alleged planning, and an earlier defense attempt to keep the brothers' Google searches out of evidence. CoinDesk's piece is available only as a headline and summary, which describe the case as the government's first criminal action over MEV.

Why the ruling matters for validators and builders

The prosecution relied on what Protos calls an honest validator theory. Coin Center's Peter Van Valkenburgh, cited by both Protos and Cointelegraph, welcomed the acquittal. He cautioned that the theory could give prosecutors a way to use wire fraud law to set their own conduct standards for validators. Cointelegraph quotes him as saying that people active on an open network might have to worry that prosecutors will later label what they did dishonest.

Clarke's description of Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment" with "no terms of use" reached that same concern from the bench. Per Decrypt, she added that the brothers' conduct may have undercut what MEV-Boost was meant to do, yet that fell short of establishing fraud. The distinction is between exploiting how software behaves and lying to someone who relies on the lie.

Scale gives the question weight. DefiLlama puts the value locked in Ethereum DeFi at $37.26 billion, and projects on Coinvote's new Ethereum tokens page operate on the same open network the judge described. None of the outlets links the ruling to any market reaction, so the effect on activity is not established.

Open questions after the acquittal

The reports do not say whether the government will appeal. That is the first question to watch, because an appeal would test Clarke's reading of the fraud statute. The footnote on due process also remains unresolved, since she declined to decide it.

A second question concerns software design. Clarke said the scheme may have frustrated MEV-Boost's intent, and Protos describes the underlying issue as a design flaw in a relay. Relay operators and validators may want to review how their code exposes bundled transactions before commitment. The outlets do not report any planned changes.

Finally, MEV is still drawing legal attention elsewhere. Cointelegraph linked to a separate class-action lawsuit involving Pump.fun and MEV trading. Whether that case leans on this ruling is not reported.

Market snapshot

AssetPrice24h7dMarket cap
Ethereum (ETH)$1,814-0.8%-12.6%$221.71 billion

CoinGecko data as of 2026-11-18 (UTC); DeFi TVL from DefiLlama: Ethereum $37.26 billion.

On Coinvote

FAQ

Why were the Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted?

Judge Jessica Clarke found that prosecutors failed to prove a material misrepresentation, which wire fraud requires. Decrypt reports that the money laundering count fell because it depended on the alleged fraud proceeds.

Does the ruling say the MEV exploit was legal or ethical?

No. Protos and Cointelegraph both report that the opinion covers only whether the evidence could support the charges. Clarke wrote that the question was not whether the conduct was right or moral, or whether it violated uncharged crimes.

How much was taken and how long did it take?

Decrypt, Protos and Cointelegraph all report about $25 million taken from trading bots in April 2023. Decrypt and Cointelegraph put the duration at roughly 12 seconds.

Sources

Written by the Coinvote news desk from reporting by CoinDesk, Protos, Cointelegraph and Decrypt. Not financial advice.


最近發表的其他文章

Binance Theft Wallets Wake Up, Sending Roughly $137 Million of ETH Onward
Binance Theft Wallets Wake Up, Sending Roughly $137 Million of ETH Onward

Ethereum

Wallets tied to October's $6.3 billion Binance theft moved about $137 million in ether after more th...

Skladon Hack Puts Home Addresses of 27,000 Trezor Buyers in Play
Skladon Hack Puts Home Addresses of 27,000 Trezor Buyers in Play

Blockchain

Trezor says an intruder at logistics firm Skladon took shipping records tied to about 27,000 hardwar...

Robinhood Listing Insider Admits Wire Fraud Over Hyperliquid Perpetuals Trades
Robinhood Listing Insider Admits Wire Fraud Over Hyperliquid Perpetuals Trades

Crypto Market Analysis

Former Robinhood engineer Huaisong Xiang pleaded guilty to wire fraud for trading Hyperliquid perpet...

World Bank Starts Testing USDC for Development Fund Payments
World Bank Starts Testing USDC for Development Fund Payments

Blockchain

The World Bank Group will test whether Circle's USDC and Citi's banking links can move development m...

ARK Rotates From Nvidia Into Block, Circle and Coinbase in Selloff
ARK Rotates From Nvidia Into Block, Circle and Coinbase in Selloff

Crypto Market Analysis

ARK Invest sold about $85 million of Nvidia shares on November 16 and bought roughly $40 million of ...

Goldman Sachs Lifts Ether and Bitcoin ETF Holdings, Cuts Strategy Stake
Goldman Sachs Lifts Ether and Bitcoin ETF Holdings, Cuts Strategy Stake

Crypto Market Analysis

Goldman Sachs reported $1.22 billion in Ether ETFs and about $1.28 billion in spot bitcoin ETFs at t...

加密資產波動劇烈且風險高:你可能損失全部資金。Coinvote 是資訊與社群平台,不構成投資建議。排名反映投票結果,推廣上架項目為付費廣告。 免責聲明 冒充身分或內容移除